Pylgrim

Studying with AI, without it doing the work.

Used to get answers, AI can make practice feel easier and exams go worse. Used to ask you questions, it can help.

The way through, on your own feet.

The risk.

In a study of nearly a thousand high school maths students, some practised with a plain AI chat. Their practice scores rose by 48%. Then they sat the exam without it, and scored 17% lower than students who never had AI at all. Bastani and others, 2025

In that group, 67% of first messages repeated the question or asked for the answer. The AI did the work, so the students did not learn it.

A second group used a version set up as a tutor, which gave hints instead of answers. Their practice scores rose by 127%, and their exam scores were no worse. They were no better either.

Practice scores

  • Plain AI chat48% higher
  • AI set up as a tutor127% higher

The exam, without AI

  • Plain AI chat17% lower
  • AI set up as a tutorNo different
Compared with students who never had AI. Practice went up. Learning did not. Bastani and others, 2025

Write it in your own words first.

People remember words they come up with themselves better than words they only read. Five experiments found the same thing. Slamecka and Graf, 1978

Explaining a text to yourself, line by line, also helps. In a small study of 24 students, those asked to explain each line understood more than those who read it twice. Chi and others, 1994

So write your notes and answers yourself. Then use AI to check them, not to make them.

Use AI to ask, not to answer.

Some ways to use it that keep the work yours:

  • Ask it to quiz you on a topic, one question at a time, and answer before you see its reply.
  • Paste your own explanation and ask what it is missing, compared with your reading.
  • Ask where in your sources a point comes from, then go and read that page.
  • Keep anything it writes apart from your notes, so you know which words are yours.

Do not trust the feeling of progress.

In the maths study, students with the tutor version thought they had done much better on the exam than they had. Bastani and others, 2025

An early study of 54 people writing essays found that those who used an AI chat struggled to quote their own essays afterwards. It is a preprint, not yet reviewed by other researchers. Kosmyna and others, 2025

The real test is whether you can do it alone, a week later.

How Pylgrim does it.

Pylgrim is built on these rules. The guide on Student checks your notes against your own sources, says what doesn't match, and asks you the next question.

It never writes the work you are marked on. Anything it writes is kept apart from your notes. Read our approach.